Why Wisconsinites Drink Brandy Old Fashioneds (2024)

admin | March 25, 2022

State history isn’t just a list of dates and names of explorers and pioneers who staked their claim in our hometowns, but it is also about the little details. These little details make up who we are as Wisconsinites, and you can’t avoid the scoop on how and what we drink. After all, Wisconsin repeatedly ranks up in the top numbers for alcohol consumption in the nation.

No doubt about it — we are serious about our drinks and the history of some of these drinks is an important part of our history. This brings us to the topic of one of Wisconsin’s favorite old fashioned co*cktails, the Brandy Old Fashioned. You can find these co*cktails at the Hotel Seymour Supperclub as well as many other Wisconsin locations. But how did this twist on the Old Fashioned even get started? Why brandy and not sugar, whiskey, and bitters like you’ll find in most other regions of the country?

Freelance writer Jeanette Hurtunravels the mystery for us.

The World’s Columbian Exposition of 1893

You can’t talk about Wisconsinite drink preferenceswithout talking about brandy. In part, Brandy Old Fashioneds are credited with the impression that Korbel Brother Brandy made on German Wisconsinites who visited the 1893 World’s Columbian Exposition in Chicago. The California brandy made such an impact on those visiting from Wisconsin that many took it back to their home state and started selling it on the regular. This popularized brandy drinking throughout the state. But there is more to the story. As Ms. Hurt dove deeper into the drinking history of Wisconsin, she found that Brandy Old Fashioned was deeply intertwined with American history and WW2!

WW2 and Good Booze!

The author uncovered a connection between Wisconsin brandy and WW2. According to old articles published in the Milwaukee Journal, post World War 2 was not a great time for liquor distributors. Many distilleries had shut down as grain and men were being sent overseas for the war effort. With the legitimate distilleries stalled, bad booze was produced on the down-low. Americans didn’t have much to choose from at the time when it came to their spirits. But Wisconsinites were in for a bit of good luck whena group of Wisconsin liquor distributors came across a cache of 30,000 cases of well-aged, Christian Brothers Brandy. What a find when the rest of the country was settling for bad booze. The brandy was quickly bought up for distribution in Wisconsin.

This windfall of good booze changed the way co*cktails were made for a while. If you had to choose between good brandy and rotgut rum, well, that’s a no-brainer. Brandy was incorporated into many co*cktails that had never been used before, including Old Fashioneds.

While many of these hybrid co*cktails did not make a lasting impression, The Brandy Old Fashioned certainly did. It has endured as a staple amongWisconsinite drink preferrences.

Why Wisconsinites Drink Brandy Old Fashioneds (2024)

FAQs

Why Wisconsinites Drink Brandy Old Fashioneds? ›

Another common tale says brandy became so popular in the Badger State out of necessity. In her book “Wisconsin co*cktails,” Jeanette Hurt explained that when whiskey and other spirits became harder to find during World War II, brandy was still widely available.

Why do wisconsinites drink brandy? ›

Brandy's popularity in Wisconsin started when a large number of German immigrants moved here in the 19th century and couldn't find their favorite drink, brandewijn. This prompted Korbel to start distilling for the public in 1889. Small-batch local distilleries produce – or have produced – brandy, too.

Why are old fashioneds so popular in Wisconsin? ›

The Wisconsin variation came about post-World War II when liquor distributors in Wisconsin found a cache of around 30,000 cases of quality brandy that they sold, which became more popular than the bad whiskey that was sold during the war, according to the book "Wisconsin co*cktails."

What is the Wisconsin state drink Brandy Old Fashioned? ›

But in Wisconsin, brandy usually replaces whiskey — and it's most often poured over a mixture of muddled cherries, orange slices, sugar and bitters. Depending on how sweet or sour the imbiber likes it, the concoction is then topped with a lemon-lime soft drink, sour mix, club soda, or some combination.

What is the official drink of the Wisconsin Old Fashioned? ›

Wisconsin crowns the brandy old fashioned as the official state co*cktail : NPR. Wisconsin crowns the brandy old fashioned as the official state co*cktail Lawmakers in Wisconsin have passed a resolution declaring the state's official co*cktail: the brandy old fashioned.

Why do people drink brandy? ›

Because of brandy's natural warming properties, it helps induce healthy sleep. In addition to that, the antibacterial nature of the drink makes it great for strengthening the immune system. Brandy can help eliminate pathogens from a person's system and can boost the immune system thanks to its many antioxidants.

What brandy is best for Old Fashioned in Wisconsin? ›

brandy: It's traditional to use Korbel (Core-bell) brandy in a Wisconsin old fashioned, but at the end of the day, any decent brandy will do. If you really can't stand to use brandy, just swap for bourbon. 7-up, sprite, squirt, or club soda: Totally your choice here based on whether you want it sweet, sour, or press.

Which state drinks the most Old Fashioned? ›

To this day Wisconsin buys copious amounts -- roughly a third of the brandy Korbel produces every year goes to Wisconsin. Now, if you remember, the liquor in the Whiskey co*cktail/Old Fashioned was interchangeable, so those brandy-loving Wisconsinites swapped out whiskey for brandy and the Brandy Old Fashioned was born.

How to order a normal Old Fashioned in Wisconsin? ›

HOW TO ORDER A WISCONSIN OLD FASHIONED IN A TAVERN
Sweet -- with a floater (aka 'wash') of Sprite or 7up,
Sour -- with a grapefruit soda like Squirt or 50/50 (actual Sour Mix works too), or
Pressed -- with a combo of soda + seltzer (less sugar, more liquor flavor).

What state makes the best Old Fashioned? ›

Ever since then, writes Robert Simonson in the book ``The Old Fashioned; The Story of the World's First Classic co*cktail,'' Wisconsin has been the top consumer of the brandy in the US, ordering about 140000 cases of the 323000 made in 2012.

Which state drinks the most brandy? ›

It may surprise some to learn that the Badger State consumes more brandy than anywhere else in the United States. In 2019, Wisconsinites accounted for more than half of the worldwide sales of Korbel brandy.

What are brandy and co*ke called? ›

More than a simple brandy and cola concoction, the Cuba Libre is a marriage of the robust Mansion House French Brandy with sweet cola and the tart lime.

Why does Wisconsin drink brandy old fashioned? ›

According to the Wisconsin State Assembly's resolution, the co*cktail variation dates back to post-WWII, when the US sent grain to war-torn Europe, and spirits like whiskey became scarce in Wisconsin. The Christian Brothers flooded the Wisconsin market with 30000 cases of brandy, making it the perfect substitute.

What is Wisconsin's signature drink? ›

Wisconsin's Twist on a Classic — The Brandy Old Fashioned

Did you know Wisconsin consumes the most brandy per capita in the country? Part of the reason is due to our official state co*cktail, the Brandy Old Fashioned. It's the Old Fashioned co*cktail you know and love, with brandy in place of whiskey.

Who invented the old fashioned drink? ›

The recipe is linked to bartender and bourbon distillery, James E. Pepper. Rumors link Pepper to The Pendennis Club before he allegedly brought the co*cktail to the Waldorf-Astoria hotel bar in New York City. Some claim Louisville as the home of the Old Fashioned while others maintain it's really NYC.

What is the most popular drink in Wisconsin? ›

1. Wisconsin's Twist on a Classic — The Brandy Old Fashioned. Did you know Wisconsin consumes the most brandy per capita in the country? Part of the reason is due to our official state co*cktail, the Brandy Old Fashioned.

What is the drinking culture in Wisconsin? ›

Wisconsin has historically ranked as one of the heaviest drinking states in the United States with a persistent drinking culture. Few studies have documented the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on alcohol consumption after the first few months of the pandemic.

Is brandy a Midwest thing? ›

The state with the biggest co*cktail culture has an enduring affection for the spirit. Most of the world drinks brandy—if they drink it at all—as an after-dinner digestif, and in most of the United States, its popularity is limited. But Wisconsinites love the stuff.

What state is top brandy drinking? ›

Wisconsin drinks more brandy than any other state, and most of our brandy consumption goes into the Wisconsin old fashioned – a muddle of sugar, bitters, orange and maraschino cherries topped with brandy and then sweet or sour soda and a bevy of garnishes.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Laurine Ryan

Last Updated:

Views: 6433

Rating: 4.7 / 5 (57 voted)

Reviews: 88% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Laurine Ryan

Birthday: 1994-12-23

Address: Suite 751 871 Lissette Throughway, West Kittie, NH 41603

Phone: +2366831109631

Job: Sales Producer

Hobby: Creative writing, Motor sports, Do it yourself, Skateboarding, Coffee roasting, Calligraphy, Stand-up comedy

Introduction: My name is Laurine Ryan, I am a adorable, fair, graceful, spotless, gorgeous, homely, cooperative person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.