Peanut Butter and Jelly Alternatives: A Foodies' Guide! (2024)

In a world filled with the classic PB&J sandwich, it's time to explore some exceptional healthy peanut butter and jelly alternatives that not only tickle your taste buds but also promote a healthier lifestyle.

Whether you're dealing with a food allergy or simply seeking new flavors, we've got you covered here at GOOD GOOD.

Let's dive into these delicious peanut butter and jelly alternatives - featuring nutritious ingredients like almond butter and hummus, that are designed to enhance your culinary experience.

9 Peanut-Free Alternatives toa Peanut Butter Sandwich

Let's look at nine of our top ideas to show you how to make a healthy peanut butter and jelly sandwich alternative.

1. Sunflower Seed Butter And Raspberry Jam Sandwich

If you're looking for a peanut butter replacement with a nutty flavor, sunflower seed butter is an excellent choice.

After trying out this recipe, we found that its creamy texture pairs perfectly with the tangy sweetness of GOOD GOOD's raspberry jam from our 99% sugar free jelly collection.

Spread them generously between two slices of whole grain bread, and you'll have a delightful sandwich that's both nutritious and delicious.

Peanut Butter and Jelly Alternatives: A Foodies' Guide! (1)

2. Ham And Cheese With Grainy Mustard On Rye Bread

For a savory twist, opt for a ham and cheese sandwich with a smear of grainy mustard. The combination of salty ham, Gruyère cheese, and the zing of mustard creates a harmonious blend of flavors.

Our findings show that choosing rye bread over other bread types adds a hearty, earthy note to this scrumptious creation.

3. Turkey, Lettuce, Tomato, And Hummus On Whole Grain Bread

For a protein-packed alternative, assemble a turkey, lettuce, tomato, and hummus sandwich on whole grain bread.

The turkey provides lean protein, while hummus adds a creamy, satisfying texture. With the crunch of fresh lettuce and tomato, every bite is a burst of freshness and flavor.

For some extra sweetness, add a drizzle of our GOOD GOOD apricot 99% sugar free jelly to break up the saltiness of the turkey and acidity in the tomato.

4. Hummus In A Pita Stuffed With Leftover Salad

Don't let your leftover salad go to waste! Fill a pita pocket with a generous dollop of hummus and your leftover salad for a satisfying and nutritious meal.

Based on our observations, the creaminess of the hummus complements the crunchy texture and flavors of the salad perfectly.

5. Soy Butter With Banana Slices On Whole Wheat Bread

For a nut-free butter alternative, try soy butter. Spread it generously on whole wheat bread and add banana slices for a sweet taste.

Drawing from our experience, the natural sweetness of bananas pairs beautifully with the mild, nutty flavor of soy butter.

Add an extra layer of decadence to your soy butter and banana sandwich with our delectable GOOD GOOD Belgian chocolate spreads.

They come in the following flavors:

  • Choco Hazel
  • Choco Orange
  • Choco White

6. Tahini (Sesame Seed Butter) With Shredded Broccoli And Carrots On A Roll

Tahini, made from ground sesame seeds, offers a unique and slightly nutty taste to any sandich. Spread it on a roll and top it with shredded broccoli and carrots for a crunchy and flavorful experience.

Add a sprinkle of our sugar free grape jelly to complement the vegetables in this recipe. After putting it to the test, adding our GOOD GOOD jelly to this combination provides a refreshing twist on the traditional sandwich.

7. Almond Butter And Sliced Apples

If you're a fan of nut butters but want to avoid peanuts, almond butter is a wonderful alternative.

Slather it onto whole wheat bread and add sliced apples for a satisfying treat. The creamy almond butter pairs wonderfully with the crispness of apples.

For an extra burst of fruity flavor, spread a dollop of our GOOD GOOD forest fruits 99% sugar free jelly onto your sandwich and get 33% more fruit content than other standard jams in every bite.

8. Cashew Butter On An English Muffin Topped With Raisins

Cashew butter brings a rich and smooth texture to your sandwiches, which is perfect for breakfast or a quick snack. Spread it on an English muffin and sprinkle some raisins on top for a touch of sweetness and chewiness.

If you're looking for that added sweetness and burst of berry flavor on your English muffin, try adding a GOOD GOOD splash of our keto cherry jelly to the mix as well.

9. Pumpkin Seed Butter And Honey Sandwich

For a unique and flavorful alternative, try pumpkin seed butter. Its earthy and slightly sweet taste pairs beautifully with honey.

Spread this duo on your favorite bread, and you'll have a sandwich that's as nutritious as it's delicious.

For an alternative to honey, try out our GOOD GOOD Sweet Like Sugar natural sweetener. We have found from using this product that it brings out the flavor of the pumpkin seed butter exceedingly well.

Conclusion

In this exploration of peanut butter and jelly alternatives, we've uncovered a world of flavors that can elevate your sandwich game while catering to various dietary preferences.

While you're crafting your next and best peanut butter and jelly alternatives, consider adding our GOOD GOOD range of jams, jellies, and spreads to the mix.

Our products are carefully crafted to enhance your healthy lifestyle without compromising on taste. With a variety of flavors to choose from, our jellies with no added sugars are the perfect accompaniment to these peanut butter and jelly alternatives.

So why not take a step towards a healthier you with us? Shop GOOD GOOD's 99% sugar-free jelly and jams now and navigate your way towards a healthier and more delicious lifestyle.

If you want to learn more, why not check out these articles below:

  • Healthy Grape Jelly Brands
  • Red Currant Jelly Alternative
  • Is Grape Jelly Gluten Free?
  • Is Jelly Gluten Free?
  • Is Jam Gluten Free?
  • Is Orange Marmalade Gluten Free?
  • Is Strawberry Jam Gluten Free?
  • Is Sugar Free Jelly Good for Diabetics?
  • Is Sugar Free Jelly Good for You?
  • Best Raspberry Jam
  • Best Fig Jam
  • Best Blueberry Jam
  • Best Apricot Jam
  • Best Cherry Jam
  • Is Jelly Vegan?
Peanut Butter and Jelly Alternatives: A Foodies' Guide! (2024)

FAQs

What's a good substitute for jelly? ›

For these reasons, corn starch is an excellent natural substitute for jelly: it has a neutral taste and it does not change the caloric intake of your dish. To use it, dissolve it in water or hot milk and add it little by little to the ingredients you want to thicken, until you get the desired consistency.

What is a savory equivalent to PB&J? ›

Creamy brie is the perfect alternative to your traditional PB&J. This cheese is rich, mild and soft enough to spread easily on crackers or bread. Pair it with a fig or apricot jam for an extra savory treat.

How to make a peanut butter and jelly sandwich without jelly? ›

Peanut Butter & Almost Any Fruit

Fruit is basically raw jelly, so putting the sliced fresh stuff on a peanut butter sandwich is an obvious move. Even without bacon, apple and banana make a good peanut butter sandwich, as do berries, pears and some stone fruits—especially if they're dried apricots.

Is there a healthy peanut butter and jelly? ›

Look for whole-grain or sprouted grain bread, 100% natural peanut butter, and jelly with no added sugar. Any combination of the above is a great way to boost the nutritional value, as well.

What is a healthy substitute for jam? ›

Preserves are the closest thing to consuming whole fruit. They contain chunks of the actual fruit, making them richer in fiber and nutrients. As with jam, though, the sugar content can vary based on the brand or recipe. In terms of health benefits, preserves generally come out on top due to their whole fruit content.

What is the healthiest jam to eat? ›

  • 8 Healthiest Jams and Jellies.
  • Best: Smucker's Low Sugar Strawberry Preserves. ...
  • Best: Polander Raspberry Fruit Spread. ...
  • Best: Raspberry Chia Smash. ...
  • Best: Blake Hill Naked Blueberry Spread. ...
  • Best: Good Good Cherry Jam. ...
  • Best: Crofter's Superfruit Just Fruit Spread. ...
  • Best: Food For Thought Truly Natural Black Cherry Preserves.
Apr 3, 2024

Is peanut butter and jelly a substitute good? ›

Substitutes are those goods that can be consumed in place of one another. These goods generally satisfy the same set of wants and needs of the consumer. Peanut butter and Jelly are substitute goods for the consumer who is indifferent between the taste of the two and can consume them as snacks in place of one another.

What are some phrases similar to you're the peanut butter to my jelly? ›

Cute ways to say I love you in English
  • I love you so matcha.
  • You're the LOL to my OMG.
  • You're the peanut butter to my jelly.
  • You're the peanut to my butter.
  • You're the crayons to my coloring book.
  • You're the guacamole to my taco.
  • You guac my world.
  • We fit together like puzzle pieces.
Oct 2, 2023

Is a PB&J healthier than a turkey sandwich? ›

What's the better sandwich option: peanut butter and jelly or turkey and cheese? A: Peanut butter and jelly. Processed ingredients in the turkey sandwich have more sodium and saturated fat. Plus, most nut butters have a good amount of protein plus some fiber to keep you fuller longer.

What is a good substitute for PB and J jelly? ›

Grilled almond butter and jelly

Made with almond butter, it holds a meatier and grainier mouthfeel than the classic peanut version. Almond butter is worth the added cost, as it is richer, thicker, and nuttier. While you may be used to pairing your nut butter with jam, we recommend giving jelly a try for this version.

What is better than peanut butter and jelly? ›

Almond butter and strawberry fruit spread is a nutrient dense alternative to peanut butter and jelly. Almond butter contains high amounts of vitamin E, which is important for skin and hair health. Almond butter also contains unsaturated fats and protein that will keep you feeling full and satisfied.

What goes well with peanut butter besides jelly? ›

Mix PB with yogurt, cinnamon, and a hint of honey or maple syrup. Dip in apples slices, celery, or spread on toast with banana slices and coconut. Mix into noodles. Thanks to its salty, nutty flavor and creamy texture, Asian-inspired noodle dishes taste divine with peanut sauce.

What are things that go together like peanut butter and jelly? ›

Matching Word Pairs
  • Salt and Pepper.
  • Peanut Butter and Jelly.
  • Red Beans and Rice.
  • Macaroni and Cheese.
  • Bacon and Eggs.
  • Bonnie and Clyde.
  • Batman and Robin.
  • Mickey and Minnie.

Is peanut butter and jelly OK for weight loss? ›

The nutritional value of a PB&J does allow this sandwich to be a part of a well-balanced diet, and it may help with weight loss. Research from Purdue University found that people better managed their weight loss regimens when nuts were included. Andrews also agrees that peanut butter and jelly can support weight loss.

What is a healthy alternative to jam? ›

Instead of processed jams or jellies, choose a homemade fruit compote or fruit salsa. A fruit compote is essentially fruit that has been chopped and cooked down to form a delicious gooey topping. Fruit salsa is simply cut fruit, usually marinated in an acid like lemon juice and served cold.

Is there a healthy version of Uncrustables? ›

Is there a healthy version of Uncrustables? Smucker's has created “healthier” Uncrustables since the original grape and strawberry jam sandwich was released. The healthier option comes in at 190 calories, only 20 calories less than the original. The healthier option also has less sugar and is paired with wheat bread.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Corie Satterfield

Last Updated:

Views: 6763

Rating: 4.1 / 5 (62 voted)

Reviews: 93% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Corie Satterfield

Birthday: 1992-08-19

Address: 850 Benjamin Bridge, Dickinsonchester, CO 68572-0542

Phone: +26813599986666

Job: Sales Manager

Hobby: Table tennis, Soapmaking, Flower arranging, amateur radio, Rock climbing, scrapbook, Horseback riding

Introduction: My name is Corie Satterfield, I am a fancy, perfect, spotless, quaint, fantastic, funny, lucky person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.